853)(Story_66)(Novel) The Girl from Ganginapar. _ Written by Junayed Ashrafur Rahman

 853)(Story_66)(Novel) The Girl from Ganginapar. _ Written by Junayed Ashrafur Rahman https://mywritingsjunayedmn1.blogspot.com/2019/12/about-me-junayed-ashrafur-rahman.html ✒ 

🌟 The video of how to translate my writings into your language.(আমার লেখাগুলো যেভাবে আপনার ভাষায় অনুবাদ করে পড়বেন,সেটার ভিডিও।) https://youtube.com/shorts/cB4L80u1IIc?si=jJV-G14OIP_qQeLA 🌟https://www.facebook.com/share/v/1GuWS35Joi/ 

Chapter One.

The Heart of the Auditorium and the Buzz of First-Year Students

As the soft golden sunlight of autumn fell across the college’s old red-brick walls, the entire campus was filled with an unusual sense of energy and excitement. The first few days of a new academic year always brought a special kind of thrill. Curious young men and women had arrived from distant villages, small towns, and different parts of the region, filling the campus with activity.

The enormous auditorium on the ground floor of the main academic building was now packed to capacity. Students had filled every available seat. First-year students had gathered for their Political Science class, a compulsory course for students from all academic departments.

According to college regulations, the introductory Political Science course was particularly important. Students from Bengali, English, Social Work, Social Welfare, History, Geography, Economics, Management, Accounting, and every other department were required to attend the class and take the examination.

As a result, students from different academic disciplines had come together in the auditorium, creating an extraordinary gathering. Some held newly purchased notebooks, while others were flipping through books they had just borrowed from the college library. Different faces, styles of clothing, and regional accents blended together, turning the entire auditorium into a lively picture of student life.

The college was called Naibani Government College. It was known as one of the oldest educational institutions in the city. Although its main building had been constructed many years earlier, it had undergone several rounds of renovation over time. A spacious field stretched out in front of the building. The administrative building stood on one side, while the library occupied the other. Several shaded seating areas had been arranged in the middle for students.

For the first-year students, everything about the college felt unfamiliar. They had left behind the familiar classrooms, assigned benches, and teachers of their schools. Now they had become part of a much larger educational institution.

Students from the History Department occupied several rows near the front of the auditorium. Among them was Rivanbi. She was about nineteen years old, of average height, with a medium-brown complexion, long hair, and an expression that always suggested curiosity. She had come to college in simple, ordinary clothes. There was nothing particularly extravagant about her appearance.

Sitting beside Rivanbi was her classmate, Oraishi. They had first met on the day of admission. They had introduced themselves to each other that very day, and since then, they usually sat together whenever they attended college.

Looking around, Oraishi said, "I had no idea that all of us would have to attend classes together in such a huge auditorium."

Rivanbi replied, "I didn't expect it either. We never had the experience of attending classes with so many students at once in school."

"Have you studied anything about Political Science before?"

"A little. But I haven't properly gone through the college textbooks yet."

"I can't even figure out where to begin just by looking at the table of contents."

Rivanbi smiled faintly.

"We'll understand it once the professor starts teaching."

Several Economics students were seated in front of them. One of them was Vraimil, who had already become acquainted with a few people after arriving at the new college. He was discussing with a classmate whether students from certain departments had heavier academic workloads than others.

Meanwhile, several Management students were sitting on the right side of the auditorium. They were introducing themselves to one another.

One student asked, "Where are you from?"

"I'm from outside the city. What about you?"

"I'm from a small town too. But I've rented a place near the college."

"Would it have been difficult to commute every day?"

"Quite difficult. That's why I arranged a place to stay here."

Small conversations and introductions were taking place throughout the auditorium.

Some students were looking for new friends. Others were trying to sit with people from their own departments. A few students stood near the auditorium entrance, holding admission documents and newly purchased textbooks.

Just then, a staff member walked over to the microphone beside the stage and began testing it.

"Hello. I'm checking to see whether the microphone is working properly."

His voice echoed throughout the auditorium.

Several students stopped talking. Gradually, others also turned their attention toward the stage.

A few moments later, Professor Pragyaditya, the Political Science instructor, entered the auditorium. He was dressed in ordinary formal attire and carried several books, a notebook, and some necessary documents.

He walked onto the stage and stood behind the podium. First, he looked at the students gathered before him. Then he leaned toward the microphone and asked,

"Have all of you come here for the Political Science class?"

A few students in the front rows answered, "Yes, sir."

The professor said, "All right. Welcome, everyone. Today, we'll get to know one another and discuss the importance of this subject."

Before he could finish speaking, conversations started again in several rows at the back.

Professor Pragyaditya noticed the disturbance. However, since it was the first day, he did not scold anyone. Instead, he waited patiently for a while.

Eventually, the auditorium became somewhat quieter.

Chapter Two.

The First Question and the Beginning of a Theoretical Debate

The auditorium was now filled with students. At that moment, a girl sitting on one of the front benches stood up and asked the professor,

"Sir, we're taking Political Science classes now. Does studying Political Science mean that we'll become political scientists?"

There was a fresh curiosity and enthusiasm in her voice. Her unexpected question made a few students in the front rows smile and laugh softly.

Standing behind the podium, Professor Pragyaditya adjusted his glasses slightly and looked at her. There was not the slightest trace of irritation on his face. Instead, his expression reflected the patient encouragement of a kind and understanding teacher.

After hearing her question, the professor replied,

"No, I would never promise you that simply attending my classes will automatically make you political scientists. However, you'll learn about various theories concerning the state and politics. These theoretical discussions may help you become influential politicians or even political scientists in the future. You've asked a very good question. Which department are you studying in?"

The professor's calm and encouraging response gradually quieted the auditorium. Everyone became more attentive.

The girl answered, "Sir, I'm a student in the History Department."

Professor Pragyaditya shifted his position slightly. Hearing such a thoughtful question from a History student had increased his interest. He smiled gently and decided to continue the conversation by asking a few personal questions to make the classroom atmosphere more comfortable.

The professor asked, "Where is your home? Where do you live?"

Hearing the question, Rivanbi straightened up slightly in her seat. Oraishi, sitting beside her, also turned toward her.

Oraishi leaned closer and whispered, "Sir is asking where you live."

Rivanbi replied, "I heard him."

"Are you going to tell him where you live?"

"Of course. What's wrong with telling someone where my home is?"

Oraishi said nothing more.

Some students in the auditorium were still trying to understand why the professor had shifted the conversation toward a student's home address. They had not expected the subject of someone's residential location to become part of the very first college class.

Rivanbi stood up.

Chapter Three.

The Shadow of Ganginapar and the Beginning of Rumors

Without the slightest hesitation, the girl raised her head and answered in a clear, confident voice. There was no nervousness in her expression. Instead, she seemed to carry a natural sense of pride in the place where she lived.

She said, "Our family owns land in Ganginapar, and our home is built on that property. We live in Ganginapar. I'm a girl from Ganginapar."

As soon as her words echoed clearly through the auditorium, the atmosphere changed almost instantly.

Professor Pragyaditya seemed unable to believe what he had just heard. In the local context of Mymensingh, the name Ganginapar carried a particular social significance and reputation. Her answer immediately captured the attention of the entire class.

Surprised, the professor asked,

"Your home is in Ganginapar? You live in Ganginapar? You're a girl from Ganginapar?"

The astonishment in his voice made the atmosphere even more intense.

Immediately, a wave of commotion spread throughout the auditorium. Students began whispering to one another. Some could hardly believe that a girl from such a prominent and well-known area was sitting among ordinary first-year students. Others began searching for some alternative explanation.

At first, Rivanbi could not understand why her simple answer had caused such a reaction.

She continued looking at the professor.

Oraishi leaned toward her ear and whispered, "Why did sir look so surprised when you mentioned your home?"

Rivanbi replied, "I don't know."

"Does sir know that your family lives in Ganginapar?"

"If he already knew, he wouldn't have needed to ask me."

Oraishi smiled slightly.

However, an entirely different conversation was taking place in another part of the auditorium.

The whispers from the back rows gradually became more audible. A boy sitting directly behind the girl from Ganginapar leaned toward another boy and said,

"That girl lives in Ganginapar. She's from Ganginapar. We always heard that there's a brothel there. Does she live in that brothel too?"

The boy's ugly remark, whispered in a low voice, quickly spread among the classmates sitting nearby. Having grown up in small towns and villages, many of the teenagers had developed an unusual curiosity about the area based on superstitions, incomplete information, and hearsay.

The boy sitting behind Rivanbi was named Vraikun. His classmate, Adraim, was sitting beside him. Both had come from small towns to attend college.

After hearing Vraikun's comment, Adraim remained silent for a moment. Then he said quietly,

"Are you sure about that?"

Vraikun replied, "I'm just telling you what I know."

"Then how does her family have a home in Ganginapar?"

"That's exactly what I can't understand."

"Maybe our understanding of that area isn't entirely accurate."

Vraikun sounded slightly irritated.

"You've already made up your mind!"

Adraim replied, "I'm not making any conclusions. I'm simply saying that you can't judge everyone who lives in an area just because you've heard its name."

Vraikun did not continue the argument.

On the other side of the auditorium, another boy turned to a classmate and said,

"Almost all of us who enrolled in the first year came here from small towns. We always thought Ganginapar meant nothing but a brothel. But this girl is proudly announcing that she's from Ganginapar and that her family lives there."

The student beside him added another comment. It was becoming increasingly clear how little some students from rural areas and small towns knew about the actual geography of the city.

The other boy said,

"You came from a small town, somewhere with at least a somewhat urban environment. But I came from a proper village. I always thought there was nothing in Ganginapar except a brothel. Now a girl from Ganginapar has joined our class. So this situation is turning out to be something completely different."

The boy's name was Orvail. He had come from a village in a neighboring district. Sitting beside him was Drumail. The two had become acquainted on the day of admission.

Drumail asked, "Have you ever been to Ganginapar?"

Orvail replied, "No."

"Then how do you know there's nothing there except a brothel?"

"I've heard people talking about it."

"Hearing something from other people isn't the same as seeing it with your own eyes."

"Have you been to Ganginapar?"

"Yes, once."

"What did you see there?"

Drumail replied, "There were plenty of shops, businesses, and crowds of people. But I didn't get a chance to explore the entire area properly."

Orvail said, "Then you're not even sure yourself."

"That's exactly why I'm saying we shouldn't make comments without knowing the whole situation."

Orvail turned his face toward the front.

Meanwhile, Rivanbi could sense that some students behind her were discussing her home and its location. However, she could not clearly hear what they were saying.

Oraishi looked somewhat annoyed and said, "They're talking about you behind your back."

Rivanbi asked, "What are they saying?"

"I can't understand everything. But they're behaving strangely after hearing the name Ganginapar."

"Let them."

"Doesn't it bother you?"

"Why should it? I simply told them where I live."

Oraishi remained silent for a moment.

Then she asked, "Is your house near the main road in Ganginapar?"

"Not very far from the main road."

"How much land does your family own?"

Rivanbi smiled slightly.

"Do I have to give a report on the size of our property in the middle of class now?"

Oraishi burst into laughter.

"No, you don't. I was just curious."

Rivanbi replied, "Our house and land have been in the family for a long time. Our relatives have lived there since my grandfather's generation."

"Then your family must be among the city's longtime residents."

"Yes."

Their conversation ended there.

Chapter Four.

Clearing Up the Misconceptions and Revealing the Real City

Meanwhile, whispers, rumors, and conflicting opinions continued spreading throughout the auditorium. Some students kept looking at the girl suspiciously, while others seemed to find the entire situation amusing.

Noticing that classroom discipline was deteriorating, Professor Pragyaditya pulled the microphone closer to his mouth with a serious expression.

Finally, he said,

"All of you, please be quiet. The main reason you're whispering among yourselves is that you haven't properly understood the situation."

There was an air of authority in his voice, the kind that came naturally from an experienced teacher. As soon as he spoke, the students fell silent and turned their attention toward him, eager to hear what he had to say.

Amid the complete silence of the auditorium, Professor Pragyaditya began explaining the truth.

He said,

"Not everyone who enrolled in the first year of this college comes from a city. Most of you have come from villages or small towns. That's why you have a different understanding of Ganginapar in Mymensingh. Many students who came here from villages and small towns have grown up believing that Ganginapar means nothing but a brothel. They assume that prostitution is the only activity that takes place there."

As the professor uttered those words, many students exchanged embarrassed or astonished looks. It seemed as though he had publicly exposed the very misconception they had secretly held in their minds.

After hearing him, several students admitted,

"Sir, that's exactly what we've always heard."

The professor smiled gently and began explaining the city's history and economic importance. He wanted to make one point absolutely clear: an entire neighborhood cannot be judged by one particular aspect of its identity or by rumors circulating about it.

He said,

"Some of what you've heard is true, and some of it is false. Yes, there is a brothel in Ganginapar. That's true. But the entire area of Ganginapar is not a brothel. Ganginapar is actually the main commercial center of Mymensingh. It was in Ganginapar that the city first began to develop. Later, the city expanded in every direction. In fact, Ganginapar is one of the most significant urban areas in greater Mymensingh.

"All kinds of commercial activities take place there. Dealers representing many different companies operate businesses in Ganginapar. Large-scale wholesale and merchant businesses are also conducted there. Property prices in Ganginapar are extremely high.

"That's why I was surprised to hear that her family has a home there. In Mymensingh, families who own property in Ganginapar are generally regarded as very wealthy."

After making his point, the professor looked across the auditorium.

"Many of you are new to this city. Some of you may not yet know all its neighborhoods and their histories. That's perfectly normal. But you should never form opinions about an entire community or its residents based on one particular reputation associated with a place."

One student raised his hand.

The professor said, "Yes, go ahead."

The boy asked, "Sir, does that mean Ganginapar is primarily known as a commercial center?"

"Calling it merely a commercial center would be an understatement. It is one of the city's oldest commercial and residential districts. There are many different kinds of businesses there, as well as numerous families who have lived in the area for generations."

Another student asked, "Sir, do ordinary people live there too?"

"Of course. There are business-owning families, working professionals, longtime residents, and newcomers. Just because a particular establishment exists in a neighborhood doesn't mean everything else in that neighborhood should be defined by it."

A student from the back row said, "Sir, we've always heard something different."

The professor replied, "Some of what you've heard may be true. But you cannot reach a complete conclusion based on incomplete information."

Rivanbi was still standing.

The professor looked at her and said, "You may sit down now."

Rivanbi took her seat.

Then the professor asked, "What's your name?"

Rivanbi stood up and replied, "Sir, my name is Rivanbi."

"Rivanbi, has your family been living in Ganginapar for a long time?"

"Yes, sir."

"Does your family own any businesses?"

"Yes, my family owns a few businesses. But I'm not personally involved in them yet."

The professor said, "All right. Your family's background is certainly a part of your life. However, your primary identity here at college is that of a student."

Rivanbi replied, "Yes, sir."

The professor turned toward the class.

"Those of you studying History must already know that several factors contribute to the development of a city. Transportation, commerce, land location, administrative importance, and population settlements all play a role in urban expansion. Ganginapar has its own history of development as well."

A female student asked, "Sir, where should we begin if we want to learn about the history of an area?"

The professor replied, "You can begin with historical documents, land records, commercial agreements, maps, and local historical accounts. History cannot be written based solely on rumors and popular stories."

Several History students nodded in agreement.

Rivanbi was listening attentively as well.

The professor then wrote several words on the board:

State, Society, Economy, Power, Citizenship.

He said, "As you study Political Science, you'll discover that these concepts are interconnected. A city's economic structure can also influence its social standing."

Gradually, the auditorium began returning to its normal classroom atmosphere.

Chapter Five.

A Change in Perspective

After the professor's detailed and informative explanation, the atmosphere inside the auditorium seemed to become much lighter. The cloud of misconceptions that had surrounded the minds of students from small towns and villages began to disappear. They now understood that Ganginapar was not simply a neighborhood associated with one particular establishment. It was also a major commercial center and an established residential area for affluent families.

By then, all the students in the auditorium had begun to understand the real character of Ganginapar. Wealthy families also lived there. No one would dare to mock Rivanbi by referring to her as the girl from Ganginapar in a derogatory way. By that point, word had already spread that her family owned a home in Ganginapar and that she came from a very wealthy family.

Although the classroom atmosphere had returned to normal, the students' curiosity about Rivanbi had not disappeared. Instead, the nature of their curiosity had changed.

Those who had been making sarcastic remarks about her address only a short while earlier were now interested in learning about her family's financial background.

Vraikun turned to Adraim, who was sitting beside him, and said, "So the girl's family must be very wealthy."

Adraim replied, "Possibly."

"Sir said that families who own homes in Ganginapar are generally considered very rich."

"He was talking about the property values and the area's commercial importance."

"Then her family must own a lot of property."

Adraim asked, "Why are you already calculating all that?"

Vraikun laughed.

"I'm just curious."

"There's nothing wrong with being curious. But we didn't come to college to investigate how much property her family owns."

Vraikun fell silent.

Meanwhile, Orvail was also thinking about the earlier conversation. He turned to Drumail and said, "I honestly didn't know that much about Ganginapar."

Drumail replied, "Neither did I."

"So we've been carrying around a misconception all this time."

"Our understanding was incomplete."

"But the professor said land prices in Ganginapar are very high."

"Yes."

"Then it must be difficult for an ordinary family to buy property there."

Drumail replied, "That depends on the location of the property and the family's financial situation."

Orvail said, "So Rivanbi's family must be among the longtime residents."

"Perhaps."

In the front row, Rivanbi was talking to Oraishi.

Oraishi said, "Everyone is looking at you differently now that they know where you live."

Rivanbi replied, "They were looking at me differently before, and now they're looking at me differently again."

"You're taking all this very calmly."

"Because it seems perfectly normal to me."

"Is your family really that wealthy?"

Rivanbi smiled slightly.

"Are you planning to investigate my family's finances now?"

"No, I just want to know."

"Our family owns a house, land, and some businesses. That's true. But I came here to attend college."

Oraishi said, "From the way you speak, it seems you don't particularly enjoy discussing your family's background."

"I don't like unnecessary conversations."

"Then weren't you angry about what happened today?"

"I was a little surprised. But what's the point of getting angry?"

"The things those boys said behind your back weren't very nice."

Rivanbi remained silent for a moment.

Then she said, "I heard them."

"You did?"

"Not everything. But I understood some of it."

Oraishi asked, "Then why didn't you say anything?"

Rivanbi replied, "The professor was already explaining the situation. There was no need for me to start another discussion."

Oraishi looked at her thoughtfully.

Just then, Professor Pragyaditya returned to the microphone.

"Now let's get back to our lesson. We'll begin by discussing what Political Science actually means."

He wrote the words Political Science on the board.

Then he looked at the students and asked, "Do any of you know what Political Science means?"

Several students raised their hands.

One answered, "Knowledge about the system of government."

Another said, "The study of state institutions and political activities."

The professor replied, "Both answers are partially correct. Political Science is a broad academic discipline. It covers many subjects, including the origin and structure of the state, systems of government, distribution of power, political institutions, citizens' rights, and international relations."

Rivanbi began taking notes in her notebook.

Oraishi opened her notebook as well.

The professor asked, "Can anyone tell me what relationship a citizen has with the state?"

A student in the front row answered, "The state provides security to its citizens."

The professor said, "That's an important aspect. What else?"

Another student replied, "The state protects citizens' rights."

"Correct. However, citizens also have certain responsibilities. The relationship between the state and its citizens is not one-sided."

The professor continued the discussion, explaining various concepts through practical examples.

Although the incident from the beginning of the class gradually faded into the background as the lesson progressed, several students still had new questions about Rivanbi.

They wanted to know what her family's house in Ganginapar looked like, how old it was, and what kinds of businesses her family owned.

However, Rivanbi made no effort to approach anyone to answer those questions.

Her attention remained focused on the lesson.

After nearly an hour, Professor Pragyaditya concluded the first part of the class.

He said, "We've had an introductory discussion today. In our next class, we'll explore the origin of the state and different theories of political thought."

He then mentioned the names of several chapters the students should read.

The students began taking notes.

A little later, the class was officially dismissed.

Conversations resumed throughout the auditorium. Some students closed their books, others packed their bags, and a few began discussing the schedules for their next classes.

Rivanbi put her notebook and pen into her bag.

Oraishi asked, "When is your next class?"

"I have a History class today."

"So do I."

"Then let's go together."

The two girls walked out of the auditorium.

Behind them, Vraikun was watching as they left. He turned to Adraim and said, "Her name is Rivanbi."

Adraim replied, "Yes, I heard it."

"Rivanbi, the girl from Ganginapar."

Adraim said, "You don't have to repeat her name so many times just to remember it."

Vraikun burst out laughing.

Meanwhile, Orvail and Drumail were also leaving the auditorium.

Orvail said, "Let's go to the cafeteria."

Drumail replied, "Sure. But one thing became clear in today's class."

"What?"

"We had known that city through just one particular reputation. Today, we learned that it has many other identities as well."

Orvail said, "You're absolutely right."

The two began walking toward the cafeteria.

The first Political Science class at the college had ended. But the discussion surrounding Rivanbi, the girl from Ganginapar, was far from over.

Chapter Six.

New Conversations in the College Cafeteria

After the Political Science class ended, students from different departments began leaving the auditorium. Some went directly to their departmental classrooms, while others decided to visit the college cafeteria. Since it was the first day of classes, many students were eager to make new friends.

Rivanbi and Oraishi walked side by side. To reach the cafeteria from the main academic building, they had to cross a wide corridor. Notice boards were mounted along both sides of the corridor. They displayed class schedules, examination announcements, and information about various cultural events.

Oraishi stopped in front of one of the notice boards and said, "Rivanbi, wait a moment. They've posted our department's class schedule here."

Rivanbi stopped.

"Let's see what time our History classes are scheduled."

Oraishi approached the notice board and began reading the document.

"We have classes five days a week. On Tuesdays and Thursdays, we have two classes each."

Rivanbi said, "Then we'll have to attend regularly."

"Of course. But I'm still not used to having so many classes in college."

"You'll get used to it."

They continued walking.

As soon as they entered the cafeteria, they noticed that many students were already sitting there. Some were drinking tea, others were having snacks, and a few were talking on their mobile phones.

There were several empty chairs at one side of the cafeteria. Rivanbi and Oraishi went over and sat down.

Oraishi asked, "What would you like to have?"

Rivanbi replied, "Tea and something to eat."

"I'll have some samosas."

Oraishi went to the counter and returned with two cups of tea, several samosas, and some biscuits.

They began eating.

Just then, they overheard a conversation at the neighboring table.

Vraikun, Adraim, Orvail, and Drumail were sitting there.

Vraikun was saying, "Ganginapar has become the biggest topic of discussion from today's class."

Orvail added, "Not just Ganginapar. The girl from Ganginapar has become a topic too."

Drumail said, "Her name is Rivanbi."

Vraikun laughed.

"You seem to have remembered her name pretty well!"

Drumail smiled and replied, "I heard it in class. I didn't need to make any special effort to remember it."

Adraim asked, "Why are you discussing this so much?"

Vraikun replied, "Because something happened on the very first day of college that none of us expected."

Orvail said, "At first, I thought Ganginapar referred only to that particular establishment."

Drumail replied, "But now you've heard what the professor said."

Vraikun said, "When the professor mentioned the major businesses and high property values in Ganginapar, I realized the place was much more important than I had thought."

Adraim asked, "So now you're interested in finding out how much property the girl's family owns?"

Vraikun laughed.

"I'm curious about that too."

Drumail joked, "Are you planning to visit her house and ask to see the property deeds?"

Everyone burst out laughing.

Meanwhile, Rivanbi and Oraishi could hear the conversation at the neighboring table.

Oraishi lowered her voice and said, "See? They're still talking about you."

Rivanbi replied, "I can hear them."

"Would you like to get to know them?"

"Why?"

"We're all studying at the same college. It's perfectly normal to become acquainted with one another."

Rivanbi placed her teacup on the table and said, "I have no problem getting to know people. But when someone hears my home address and develops strange ideas about me, I don't feel particularly interested in getting acquainted with that person."

Oraishi said, "Did you hear what Vraikun said?"

"I heard some of it."

"He talks a little too much."

Rivanbi smiled faintly.

"Then let him keep his words to himself."

Just then, Vraikun stood up from the neighboring table and walked toward them.

He asked, "Are you both students in the History Department?"

Oraishi replied, "Yes."

"I'm Vraikun. I study in the Management Department."

Oraishi introduced herself.

"I'm Oraishi. And this is Rivanbi."

Vraikun looked at Rivanbi and asked, "You live in Ganginapar, right?"

Rivanbi replied, "Yes."

"Sir talked about you in class today."

"You heard that, didn't you?"

Vraikun looked slightly uncomfortable.

He said, "Actually, we were a little surprised when we heard where you live."

Rivanbi asked directly, "Why were you surprised?"

Vraikun replied, "We had a different idea about Ganginapar."

"What kind of idea?"

Vraikun remained silent for a moment.

Then he said, "We knew there was a brothel there."

Rivanbi replied, "There is a brothel there. But why should that mean everyone living in the entire neighborhood has to be identified in the same way?"

Vraikun said, "No, that's not right."

Rivanbi replied, "Then you understand the point."

Vraikun nodded.

"Yes, I understand."

After that, he returned to the neighboring table.

Oraishi said, "You speak very directly."

Rivanbi replied, "When someone asks a question, I answer it."

"Vraikun seemed a little uncomfortable after what you said."

"There's no reason for him to feel uncomfortable."

A little later, they finished their tea and left the cafeteria.

Chapter Seven.

The Family Home in Ganginapar

After finishing her first day of classes, Rivanbi prepared to return home. Various vehicles were moving along the road outside the college's main entrance. Some students were boarding buses, others were taking rickshaws, while a few were leaving in their families' cars.

Rivanbi's family owned a private car. However, she generally did not travel to college with the family driver. Her father wanted her to enjoy her college life independently and develop normal friendships with other students.

That day, too, she walked some distance from the college gate before getting into the family car.

The driver was Traimbor.

Traimbor asked, "How was your first day at college, ma'am?"

Rivanbi replied, "It was good."

"Did you make any new friends?"

"I met someone. Her name is Oraishi."

"That's good."

The car started moving.

Shops, commercial establishments, and crowds of people lined both sides of the road. After a while, the car entered the city's busy commercial district.

Rivanbi looked out the window.

She had been familiar with the streets of this city since childhood. She recognized many of the shops, old buildings, markets, businesses, and familiar faces throughout Ganginapar.

After passing through a busy road, the car finally stopped in front of her family's home.

The house had several floors and a spacious entrance. There was a small garden on one side and a parking area for the family's vehicles on the other.

The main gate opened, and the car entered the property.

Rivanbi stepped out and walked inside.

Her mother was sitting in the living room. Her name was Arushmita.

Seeing her daughter, Arushmita asked, "How was your first day at college?"

Rivanbi replied, "It was good."

"Did you have classes?"

"Yes. We had Political Science first."

"What did the professor teach?"

"He gave us an introductory discussion about the state and politics."

"Did you make any new friends?"

"I met someone named Oraishi."

"Which department is she in?"

"The History Department."

Arushmita smiled gently.

"Since you're studying the same subject, you can study together."

Rivanbi replied, "Yes."

Just then, her father came out from inside the house. His name was Adraibon.

He managed the family's business operations. They owned several plots of land, commercial properties, and businesses in Ganginapar. The family had been involved in business for generations.

Seeing his daughter, Adraibon asked, "What happened at college today?"

"Something interesting happened in my first class."

"What happened?"

"My Political Science professor asked where our home was. I told him it was in Ganginapar."

Adraibon asked, "And then?"

"He was very surprised."

"Why?"

"He asked me several times whether we really lived in Ganginapar."

Adraibon laughed.

"What's so surprising about the name Ganginapar?"

Rivanbi replied, "The professor discussed our neighborhood's social and economic importance in considerable detail."

Adraibon said, "Well, that's good."

Rivanbi sat down on the sofa and continued, "But some students had misconceptions about Ganginapar. They thought it was nothing but a brothel."

Arushmita looked concerned.

"Why would they think that?"

Rivanbi replied, "They probably don't know much about the actual area."

Adraibon said, "Many people know the name of a city without knowing its history or the different parts within it."

Rivanbi said, "The professor explained everything in class."

"Did anyone say anything afterward?"

"A boy came over and spoke to me in the cafeteria."

"What did he say?"

"He told me that they had a different idea about Ganginapar."

Adraibon asked, "What did you tell him?"

"I told him that an entire neighborhood cannot be judged by one particular characteristic."

Adraibon looked at his daughter and smiled.

"All right. Focus on your studies."

After that, he went to his office.

A little later, Rivanbi went to her own room.

Her bedroom was on the second floor. On one side stood a study desk, bookshelves, and a computer. Through the window, she could see part of the busy road in Ganginapar.

She took her books out of her bag and placed them on the study desk.

Then she picked up her mobile phone and noticed a message from Oraishi.

Oraishi had written, "Have you finished writing today's class notes?"

Rivanbi replied, "Yes, I've written some of them."

Oraishi sent another message.

"Will you come to college a little early tomorrow?"

Rivanbi asked, "Why?"

"I want to visit the library."

"All right."

They then agreed on a time to meet the following day.

Chapter Eight.

Expanding Acquaintances and New Curiosity

The following morning, Rivanbi arrived at college early. Compared with the first day, she was beginning to feel more comfortable in her new surroundings. After entering through the main gate, she headed directly toward the library.

Oraishi was already waiting there.

Oraishi said, "You're right on time today."

Rivanbi replied, "You came early too."

"I thought you might be a little late."

"Why?"

"Your home is in Ganginapar. It doesn't take long to get to college from there."

Rivanbi laughed.

"Then I shouldn't have any reason to be late."

The two girls entered the library.

Inside, there were several large bookshelves. Books on Political Science, History, Economics, and Literature were arranged in separate sections.

Oraishi began looking for a few History textbooks.

Rivanbi picked up a book as well.

Just then, a girl standing nearby asked, "Are you both students in the History Department?"

Oraishi replied, "Yes."

The girl introduced herself.

"I'm Vraishali."

Rivanbi said, "I'm Rivanbi, and this is Oraishi."

Vraishali said, "We haven't met before."

Oraishi replied, "We've been sitting together since the first day."

Vraishali explained, "I was sitting farther back, so we didn't get a chance to meet."

The three girls chatted for a while.

Vraishali asked, "Where do you both live?"

Oraishi mentioned the name of her neighborhood.

Then Vraishali turned toward Rivanbi.

Rivanbi replied, "Ganginapar."

Vraishali immediately said, "Oh, you're that girl from Ganginapar!"

Rivanbi smiled faintly.

"Has my name already spread throughout the college?"

Vraishali replied, "I heard a few people talking about you after yesterday's Political Science class."

Oraishi said, "See? Your neighborhood's name has become part of your identity."

Rivanbi replied, "I don't have a problem with that."

Vraishali said, "I actually know a little about Ganginapar's commercial district. One of my relatives runs a business there."

Rivanbi asked, "Really?"

"Yes. But I don't know anything about your family."

Rivanbi replied, "There's no need to."

Vraishali smiled slightly.

"That's true."

After that, they sat down with their books.

A little later, several students arrived outside the library. Vraikun and Adraim were among them.

Vraikun said to Adraim, "There's Rivanbi."

Adraim replied, "I can see her."

"Let's go and talk to her."

"We already introduced ourselves yesterday."

"We can get to know her better."

Adraim smiled and asked, "First tell me what you actually want to know."

Vraikun replied, "I want to know what her family's house in Ganginapar looks like."

Adraim asked, "Do you really need to go into the library just to ask that?"

Vraikun did not answer.

Meanwhile, Orvail and Drumail were also approaching the library.

Orvail said, "Looks like we'll see them again today."

Drumail replied, "We're in the same college. We might see them every day."

Orvail said, "After what happened yesterday, everyone seems to know that girl."

Drumail replied, "Her identity isn't limited to being a resident of Ganginapar. She's also our classmate."

Orvail said, "That's true."

Inside the library, Rivanbi and Oraishi were reading their books.

They were writing several important points in their notebooks.

Suddenly, Oraishi asked, "Rivanbi, do you think everyone at college will know you only as the girl from Ganginapar?"

Rivanbi looked up from her book.

"Why?"

"Because everyone has been discussing the same thing for the past two days."

Rivanbi replied, "Something else will happen in a few days. Then everyone will start discussing something different."

Oraishi said, "You're quite relaxed about it."

Rivanbi replied, "Because I came to college to study. I don't have time to spend all day thinking about what other people are discussing."

Oraishi smiled.

Just then, a library staff member approached them and said, "When you've finished reading those books, please return them to their designated places."

Oraishi replied, "Yes, we will."

They returned to their reading.

Chapter Nine.

Ganginapar's Business Connections

That afternoon, after returning home from college, Rivanbi noticed that her father was meeting with several businessmen in the living room. Some documents, accounting ledgers, and property-related papers were spread across the table.

Adraibon was telling one of the businessmen, "The shops on the second floor of this commercial building will be available for rent starting next month. However, we'll make a decision only after thoroughly reviewing the rental agreements."

The businessman replied, "Our company is interested in opening a branch there."

Adraibon said, "Please submit your proposal in writing. Include the rental amount, duration of the agreement, and all other relevant terms."

Another businessman said, "We would prefer a long-term agreement."

Adraibon replied, "We can discuss that. However, the agreement must also cover building maintenance and security arrangements."

Rivanbi stood near the doorway and listened for a while.

Her father noticed her and said, "You're home?"

"Yes."

"How was college?"

"It was good."

"Go ahead and study. We're just finishing up some business."

Rivanbi headed toward her room.

A little later, the businessmen left.

Before going to his office, Adraibon called his daughter.

"Rivanbi, come here for a moment."

Rivanbi walked over to him.

Adraibon asked, "What did you study at college today?"

"The introductory concepts of Political Science."

"Good."

Rivanbi asked, "Dad, if someone at college asks about our family's businesses in Ganginapar, what should I tell them?"

Adraibon looked surprised.

"Why? Has someone asked you?"

"Not directly yet. But a few people seem interested."

Adraibon replied, "Just tell them what you know. Our family owns businesses. We have several commercial properties and some land. None of that is a secret."

Rivanbi asked, "Do I have to tell them the size of our business operations too?"

Adraibon laughed.

"That's not something you need to discuss in personal conversations."

Rivanbi replied, "That's what I was thinking."

Adraibon continued, "Our family has lived in Ganginapar for generations. The family members know about our businesses and properties. None of that has any direct connection to your college studies."

Rivanbi said, "I understand."

Then she returned to her room.

That evening, the entire family sat together at the dinner table.

Arushmita asked, "Do your college friends want to visit our house?"

Rivanbi replied, "No one has mentioned it yet."

"You can invite your friends over."

"Of course. But I haven't gotten to know everyone yet."

Adraibon said, "You'll get to know them gradually."

While eating, Rivanbi said, "I met a few more people at the library today."

"That's good," Adraibon replied.

"However, many of them are still curious about Ganginapar."

Arushmita asked, "Does that bother you?"

Rivanbi replied, "It makes me a little uncomfortable. I want everyone to know me as a student."

Adraibon said, "Building an identity takes time."

After finishing dinner, Rivanbi returned to her study room.

A History textbook was already open on her desk. She began reading several chapters in preparation for the following day's classes.

Outside, vehicles continued moving along the roads of Ganginapar. Lights shone from the shops, and the commercial district had not yet settled down for the night.

She could see the scene through her bedroom window.

For Rivanbi, this environment was nothing new. She had grown up in this neighborhood since birth. But after starting college, she had begun to realize how differently people could perceive the same city.

Then she turned her attention back to the pages of her book.

Chapter Eighteen

Different Realities Within the Same Neighborhood

After collecting the information, the students began exploring different parts of Ganginapar.

On one side stood long-established businesses. On the other were residential houses. New multistory buildings had been constructed in some places, while older structures remained unchanged in others.

Along one street, several small shops stood side by side. Their employees were arranging products on the shelves. A short distance away, several elderly people were sitting in front of an old house.

Vraishali said, “I never realized that one neighborhood could have so many different environments.”

Rivanbi replied, “People usually consider the part they hear about most often to be representative of the entire neighborhood. But the reality is much broader.”

Drumail said, “Many students at our college made the same mistake.”

“That could become an important part of our project,” Rivanbi said. “We can examine how people's perceptions develop and how those perceptions change when they learn the actual facts.”

They stopped in front of an old house. They had an opportunity to speak with an elderly member of the family that owned it.

He explained that his family had lived in Ganginapar for many years. He had witnessed the changes in the neighborhood's commercial activities and residential environment firsthand.

Vraikun asked, “Was there this much traffic in the area in the past?”

“No. There were far fewer vehicles back then. Business practices were different, too. The transportation of goods, the operation of shops, and the movement of people have all changed.”

Adraim asked, “Have the residential houses changed significantly?”

“Very much. Some people have renovated their old houses. Others have constructed new buildings. Some families have sold their inherited properties and moved elsewhere.”

Rivanbi asked, “Do you think these changes are affecting the neighborhood's identity?”

The elderly man thought for a moment before answering.

“Things are changing. But a neighborhood's identity is not defined solely by its old buildings. The people who live here, their businesses, their memories, and their everyday lives are all part of its identity.”

Rivanbi wrote his words in her notebook.

That afternoon, they spoke with several more families. Some were involved in business. Others worked in different professions. Some had been earning their livelihoods by renting out their properties for years.

Each family had a different experience. However, one point became clear from all their accounts: Ganginapar could not be defined by a single identity.

Chapter Nineteen

Uncomfortable Questions

After returning to college, the project members began organizing the information they had collected. Each of them had separate interview records and photographs of documents.

A student named Vrainak joined their team. He was an economics student, and Professor Pragyaditya had assigned him to help analyze the project's findings.

Vrainak said, “The information you've collected clearly shows the area's economic importance. But how are you going to present its social realities?”

Rivanbi replied, “We're working on that. However, we must not portray people from any particular community or profession as if they were all the same.”

Vrainak asked, “Will you directly mention the negative perceptions people have about Ganginapar?”

“Of course. But we cannot present allegations or accusations as facts without supporting evidence. The reality of one part of the neighborhood is not the same as the identity of the entire area.”

Oraishi said, “We could conduct a small survey among the students. We could compare what they knew about Ganginapar before with what they know now.”

Vraishali said, “It would be better not to disclose anyone's personal identity in the survey.”

Rivanbi replied, “Agreed. We'll collect the responses without asking for names.”

They began preparing the questions.

The first question asked what kind of information the respondents had previously known about Ganginapar.

The second asked where they had obtained that information.

The third asked about their perceptions of the area's businesses and residential environment.

The fourth asked whether their previous opinions had changed after learning new information.

Once the questions were ready, the students showed them to Professor Pragyaditya.

He said, “This is a good survey. However, keep the wording neutral. Don't ask questions in a way that makes people feel you're treating their previous opinions as something wrong or shameful.”

Rivanbi said, “We simply want to understand how people obtain information and whether they verify it.”

“Then this will be suitable for a research project,” the professor replied.

He reviewed the questions and suggested a few revisions. The students accepted his recommendations.

Chapter Twenty

Old Documents from the Family

That evening, after returning home, Rivanbi spoke with her father.

“Dad, today we collected information about several old businesses. Many people have historical property documents, but not all of those records have been preserved.”

Adraibon said, “That's understandable. Document preservation wasn't as organized in the past as it is today. Many families have even lost important papers.”

“Are all our family's old property documents still here?”

“Not all of them. Some are kept elsewhere. A few records were in your grandfather's business office.”

“Where are they now?”

“In some old cabinets. You can look through them if you want.”

Rivanbi said, “They could be important for my project.”

Adraibon suggested that she visit the office the following day.

The next morning, Rivanbi went to the business office with her father. Traimbor drove them there.

An old storage room behind the office contained several cabinets and a few wooden boxes. With the help of the employees, Adraibon brought the boxes out.

The first box contained old letters, account books, and several business receipts.

The second contained property deeds and tax payment records.

When they opened the third box, they found several old maps and plans.

Rivanbi picked up one of the documents and asked, “Is this a map of an old section of Ganginapar?”

Adraibon examined the paper carefully.

“It could be. But we can't be certain without knowing when it was prepared and what purpose it served.”

“Several street names are written here.”

“Yes. Some of those names are still in use, while others have been changed.”

Rivanbi took a photograph of the map. Then she noticed a receipt. It contained the purchase price of a plot of land and the date of the transaction.

She asked, “Does our family still own this land?”

“No. One portion of that property was sold a long time ago. The remaining portion was later divided through a family settlement.”

“Then we might be able to trace the history of the ownership changes, too.”

“We might. But we'll have to compare the old deeds with the current records.”

Rivanbi realized that collecting old papers would not be enough for the project. She would also need to verify their authenticity and determine how they related to the property's present status.

She prepared a complete inventory of the documents. She recorded the approximate date of each one, its subject, and the kind of information it might help verify.

As they were returning home, Adraibon said, “I'm glad to see how carefully you're handling this project.”

Rivanbi replied, “I don't want this project to be just about getting a good grade in college. I want to present reliable information about Ganginapar that people need to know.”

Adraibon looked at his daughter and said, “Then never compromise when it comes to facts. If any information about our own family turns out to be incorrect, make sure you correct that, too.”

Rivanbi nodded. She realized that the scope of the project had grown considerably.

Chapter Twenty-One

Preparing to Verify the Information

The next day, after arriving at college, Rivanbi went to the library with the documents collected for the project. She had organized the photographs of the old deeds and maps from her father's business office on a computer. Beside each photograph, she had recorded the document's possible date, subject, and source.

Oraishi looked at the photographs on the computer screen and said, “You've organized everything quite carefully. But some of the writing in these documents is difficult to read.”

“Yes. Parts of the old papers have become unclear. I'll need help from an experienced employee at my father's office to read them.”

Vraishali asked, “Are we going to include these documents directly in our project?”

“We'll use the information from the documents we can verify. We won't present anything we cannot verify as confirmed fact.”

Vraikun handed them a sheet of paper. It contained the names and locations of several businesses in Ganginapar, along with possible interview dates.

“I've contacted a few businesses,” he said. “Two owners have agreed to give interviews. One of them may also allow us to examine some of the company's old account books.”

Rivanbi looked at the list and said, “That's good. But interviewing only the owners won't be enough. We should also speak with the employees.”

Adraim said, “The employees may not know much about the businesses' histories.”

“Not everyone will. But they may have firsthand knowledge of working conditions, wages, working hours, goods transportation, and changes in business operations.”

Vrainak said, “We need that information to understand economic changes. We can't assess a neighborhood's economic condition simply by looking at property prices or the size of its businesses.”

Rivanbi agreed with him.

A little later, Professor Pragyaditya arrived at the library. The students showed him the documents.

The professor examined several photographs carefully. Then he said, “There's one thing you must remember. An old deed may serve as evidence of an event, but you cannot interpret it without understanding its purpose and context. A property deed can provide information about ownership. However, to understand what activities took place on that land, you'll need additional evidence.”

Rivanbi asked, “Sir, what should we do if we find multiple deeds for the same property?”

“Examine all of them. Compare the dates, deed numbers, owners' names, and property descriptions. If there were changes in ownership, document those changes in chronological order. If you find inconsistencies in any document, don't conceal them.”

Vrainak asked, “What should we do if the information in a deed doesn't match the official records?”

The professor replied, “Mention the discrepancy separately. Until it has been verified, don't declare either party right or wrong. Research is about identifying inconsistencies in information, not reaching conclusions through assumptions.”

The students wrote down his instructions.

Chapter Twenty-Two

The Voices of Ganginapar's Residents

On the weekly day off, the project members returned to Ganginapar. This time, their goal was to interview people from different professions and occupations.

First, they visited an old wholesale business. There, they spoke with an employee who had worked at the establishment for many years.

Vraishali asked, “How long have you been working here?”

“About thirty years,” the employee replied.

“What kinds of changes have you seen in the business during that time?”

“A lot has changed. The methods we used to transport goods are no longer the same. Communication is faster now. Accounting methods have changed, too. In the past, we recorded many things in account books. Now we use computers.”

Adraim asked, “Have the employees' responsibilities changed as well?”

“Definitely. In the past, one employee often had to handle several different tasks. Now the work is divided. Some people handle accounts, others receive goods, and others arrange deliveries.”

Rivanbi asked, “Have these changes made things easier for employees?”

“Some things have become easier. But the workload has increased, too. Working hours used to follow one pattern. Now they vary depending on the nature of the business.”

They recorded his answers.

Next, they visited a transportation-related business. There, they spoke with a person responsible for transporting goods.

He explained that businesses in Ganginapar maintained connections with different areas. Transportation played an important role in wholesale trading, warehousing, and the distribution of goods.

Vraikun asked, “Is transporting goods easier now than it was in the past?”

“In some ways, yes. Transportation and communication systems have improved. But traffic congestion, loading and unloading goods, and finding designated places to park vehicles are still problems.”

Rivanbi asked, “Do these problems affect businesses?”

“Of course. If goods don't arrive on time, business owners suffer losses. Traffic congestion also frustrates customers.”

They took notes on the problems affecting transportation.

After that, they spoke with several shop employees. One of them explained that the area's commercial importance attracted large numbers of people every day. Customers, suppliers, employees, and business owners were constantly moving through the neighborhood. As a result, the livelihoods of many people were connected to its economic activities.

Oraishi said, “At first, we focused only on the large businesses. But we won't get the complete picture if we leave out small shops and their employees.”

Rivanbi replied, “Exactly. Small businesses are just as much a part of the area's economy as large establishments.”

After completing the interviews, they went to a residential street and spoke with several residents. Their accounts brought up issues involving rent, traffic congestion, water supply, waste management, and the maintenance of old houses.

One resident said, “There's plenty of business activity and movement here. But residential problems exist, too. If you look only at large buildings and expensive land, you won't understand the everyday difficulties people face.”

Rivanbi asked, “Do you think residential facilities should receive equal attention alongside the area's development?”

“Absolutely. Businesses may expand and new buildings may go up, but development will remain incomplete if residents' needs aren't addressed.”

Rivanbi recorded the comment.

That day's interviews added a new dimension to their project. Ganginapar's identity could not be explained solely through its commercial importance or property values. Employment, residential life, transportation, public services, and social relationships were equally important.

# Chapter Twenty-Three

## The Origins of Old Perceptions

After returning to college, the students began conducting their survey. They distributed questionnaires among students from different departments. Respondents were not required to provide their names or personal information.

Vraishali was surprised when she reviewed the first few responses.

“Look at this. Many people know nothing about Ganginapar. Others have only heard about one particular section of it.”

Oraishi said, “Some wrote that they had heard about it from people they knew. But they couldn't provide any specific source of information.”

Vrainak said, “This could be a common way in which social perceptions develop. Sometimes people hear partial information and form opinions about an entire neighborhood.”

Rivanbi said, “But we shouldn't treat this as merely a problem of perception. We also need to understand where the information comes from.”

A student approached them with a completed questionnaire and said, “I used to think that the entire Ganginapar area was associated with that one particular identity. But after hearing about your project, I realized that the situation isn't that simple.”

Rivanbi asked, “Where did you get that impression in the first place?”

“I heard it from my friends. Nobody ever told me about the neighborhood's history or its businesses.”

“Do you now think it's fair to judge an entire neighborhood based on the identity of just one section?”

The student replied, “No. I think I should have learned the facts first.”

Rivanbi said nothing more. She simply recorded the response.

A little later, another student approached to submit a questionnaire.

“Will your project also include that particular section of the neighborhood?” the student asked.

Rivanbi replied, “If we find reliable information about the area you're referring to, we'll include it where relevant. But we won't disclose anyone's private life or personal identity.”

“Does that mean you'll leave out the entire subject?”

“No. There's no reason to exclude something that is part of reality. However, we must not exaggerate it. It would also be wrong to present the activities of one particular location as the identity of all Ganginapar.”

The student nodded.

After completing the survey, the team organized the responses into separate categories. They calculated how many respondents had previously known about the area's businesses, how many knew about its residential environment, and how many had relied mainly on things they had heard from others.

However, the students decided not to present the survey results as representing the opinions of the entire city's population. All the respondents were students from the same college. Their experiences alone could not establish the views of a much larger population.

After reviewing the results, Professor Pragyaditya said, “It's good that you've taken this precaution. Your conclusions must remain within the limits of your sample.”

Vrainak asked, “Sir, can we use percentages when presenting the survey results?”

“Yes, you can. But make sure you mention the total number of respondents. Clearly explain the types of questions you asked, too. If respondents were allowed to select more than one answer, mention that as well.”

Rivanbi said, “We don't want readers to misunderstand the results.”

The professor replied, “Collecting information is not the only important part of research. Presenting that information accurately is equally important.”

# Chapter Twenty-Four

## The Expansion of Its Economic Identity

Over the next few days, the project members continued gathering information about business and commerce in Ganginapar.

They prepared a list of different types of businesses. They organized information about wholesalers, retail shops, product suppliers, transportation companies, company dealerships, and financial service providers into separate categories.

A manager at one business explained that Ganginapar's location and long-established commercial connections had encouraged various companies to operate there.

Adraim asked, “What is the biggest advantage of this area for a business?”

The manager replied, “The connections between customers and business owners. You can find many different products and services here. That makes it possible to conduct various types of commercial activities within the same neighborhood.”

Vraikun asked, “Does the high price of land create problems for new businesses?”

“In some cases, yes. When shop and office rents are high, operating costs increase for new entrepreneurs. On the other hand, being located here can be an advantage for established businesses.”

Rivanbi said, “So a high property value doesn't necessarily benefit every business.”

“Exactly. You have to consider property prices, rent, the number of customers, transportation, and the nature of the business.”

They recorded the manager's comments.

During their next interview, a small business owner explained that competing with large companies was difficult for smaller businesses. They had to manage shop rent, purchasing costs, and employee salaries. However, familiar customers and long-standing business relationships helped them stay in business.

Vraishali said, “We should include the problems faced by small business owners alongside the information about large companies.”

Rivanbi replied, “Yes. Ganginapar's economic identity wasn't created by large business owners alone. Small shops, employees, suppliers, and transportation workers are all part of it.”

Vrainak said, “We could create a separate section explaining how businesses of different sizes are connected to one another.”

Everyone agreed with the suggestion.

That day, they collected information from several more businesses. Some had preserved their old business licenses. Others had tax payment receipts. In a few cases, they could obtain only verbal accounts of how the businesses had started.

They carefully recorded the source of every piece of information. They labeled spoken accounts as oral information and records supported by documents as documentary information.

# Chapter Twenty-Five

## The Changing Residential Environment of the City

The next stage of the project focused on changes in the residential environment.

Rivanbi spoke with her father to learn what had changed around her family's old house in Ganginapar.

Adraibon said, “There used to be open spaces in front of many houses. The buildings also had different designs. Now the use of land has changed. Some people have demolished their old houses and built new buildings. Others use part of their buildings for commercial purposes.”

“Have these changes increased residential problems?”

“Some problems have become more serious. There are more vehicles and more people moving around. At the same time, transportation and access to products have improved.”

“Have all families benefited from these changes?”

“No. The value of some properties has increased. Some owners are earning better rental income. But for people who don't own their homes, paying rent can become difficult. So the effects of these changes aren't the same for everyone.”

Rivanbi said, “We need to show that difference in our project.”

Adraibon replied, “Absolutely. But there's no need to disclose any family's private financial situation. Presenting the general trends will be enough.”

The following day, the project members visited several houses in the residential areas. They saw old houses alongside newly constructed buildings. Some houses had shops on the ground floor, with families living on the upper floors. Other buildings were used entirely for residential purposes.

One homeowner explained that his family had originally used the entire house only as a residence. Later, they rented out part of the ground floor, which increased their household income.

Another resident said, “Commercial activity has increased the number of people moving through this area. But it creates problems when vehicles are parked in front of our homes.”

Vraishali asked, “Which improvements do you think are most important for the neighborhood?”

He replied, “Better road management, waste removal, safe transportation, and proper drainage. Businesses can continue to operate, but the problems faced by residents must also be addressed.”

Rivanbi asked, “Have you reported these problems to the local authorities?”

“Some of them have been reported. Work has been done in certain areas, but other problems remain unresolved.”

They recorded the interview.

Afterward, they spoke with several tenants. Their responses revealed different reasons why people chose to rent homes in Ganginapar. Some wanted to live close to their workplaces. Others lived there for business-related convenience. Some did not want to leave because their families had lived in the neighborhood for many years.

One tenant said, “There are advantages to living here. But the rent is expensive, too. Not everyone can afford the same kind of housing.”

Adraim said, “Even though land prices are high in this neighborhood, that doesn't mean every resident is wealthy.”

Rivanbi replied, “That's another important point. You can't determine the financial condition of every resident simply by looking at the value of the properties in an area.”

# Chapter Twenty-Six

## A New Discussion in the Classroom

During the next political science class, Professor Pragyaditya asked the students about the progress of their project.

Rivanbi said, “Sir, we've collected information about Ganginapar's businesses, residential environment, transportation, and people's social experiences. We've also found some old documents, although a few details still need to be verified.”

The professor said, “Good. Have you also identified the differences between the various sections of the neighborhood?”

“Yes, sir. The same area contains commercial establishments, residential houses, small shops, and other activities.”

The professor asked, “Then is it reasonable to define the entire neighborhood by the identity of just one particular section?”

Vrainak replied, “No, sir. That would leave out the realities of the other sections.”

The professor asked, “How can you connect this issue to the study of political science?”

Adraim answered, “Different regions, communities, and institutions within a state have their own characteristics. We can't explain an entire state by describing only one of its parts.”

The professor was pleased with the answer.

“Exactly. The identity of a society or a neighborhood has many dimensions. When too much importance is given to one characteristic, the others become overshadowed. You can make this point clear in your project.”

Another student asked, “Sir, are incomplete facts the only reason people develop mistaken perceptions?”

The professor replied, “Not always. Personal experiences, social discussions, the media, commonly held beliefs, and sometimes deliberate propaganda can influence people's perceptions. However, we cannot say which factor was responsible in a particular case without evidence.”

Rivanbi said, “Our college survey showed that many students had relied on information they heard from people they knew.”

“That's one of your survey findings. But don't present it as something that applies to everyone.”

“Yes, sir.”

The professor continued, “You can briefly mention the misunderstanding you encountered on the first day at the beginning of your project. However, don't write about it in a way that humiliates any individual. Use the incident to explain the effects of incomplete information.”

Rivanbi nodded.

After a moment, the professor added, “There's one more thing. You don't need to deny a particular social reality that exists in Ganginapar. But you must not present that reality as the identity of the entire neighborhood, either. Keep every fact within its proper context.”

The students understood his point.

# Chapter Twenty-Seven

## A Disagreement Over an Interview

As the project progressed, a problem emerged. During an interview, one person had made several negative statements about Ganginapar. However, he could not provide any documents or details of specific incidents to support his claims.

Vraikun asked, “Should we leave out his statements?”

Vrainak said, “Before excluding them entirely, we should consider which part of our research they might be relevant to.”

Oraishi said, “But we can't verify the statements.”

Rivanbi replied, “Then we cannot use them as established facts. However, if we're discussing perceptions commonly held among people, we may mention them as personal opinions, while keeping the person's identity confidential.”

Vraishali asked, “Should we also collect statements from other residents to compare with his comments?”

“Yes. But we shouldn't automatically reject one person's statement just because someone else says something different. We'll verify whatever we can.”

They decided to gather additional information about the specific claims made by the interviewee.

The following day, they spoke with several residents of the area concerned. Some disagreed with his statements. Others suggested that his experience might have been related to a particular period or a specific incident. A few acknowledged that the neighborhood had certain problems but said those problems should not be presented as the identity of the entire area.

One resident said, “If there's a problem somewhere, people should talk about it. But it's unfair to judge everyone in the same way because of that problem.”

Rivanbi said, “We want to identify and present the problems separately.”

“That's good. Problems won't be solved if people hide them. But exaggerating them will mislead people, too.”

After the interview, Rivanbi realized that the most difficult part of the project was remaining impartial. They couldn't exclude a statement simply because they disliked it. At the same time, they couldn't accept something as true merely because someone had said it.

After returning to college, they informed Professor Pragyaditya about the matter.

The professor said, “You've made the right decision. In research, you must clearly distinguish between opinions and verified information. Mention the source, date, and context of each statement. If there's no supporting evidence, don't present it as an established event.”

Vrainak asked, “Sir, could we create a separate section titled 'Common Perceptions and Verified Information'?”

“That would be a good idea. It will help readers understand which statements reflect people's opinions and which facts are supported by documents or multiple sources.”

# Chapter Twenty-Eight

## Preparing the Project Report

After collecting all the information, the students began writing their report.

The first section discussed Ganginapar's location and historical development. The second covered business, commerce, and economic activities. The third focused on the residential environment and public services. The fourth examined people's social experiences and commonly held perceptions.

Rivanbi prepared the first draft of the opening section. She wrote that Ganginapar was an important urban area in Mymensingh. It had played a significant role in the city's development. Over time, commercial activities had expanded, and connections with surrounding areas had increased.

Vrainak wrote the section on economic activities. It covered business establishments, wholesale and retail markets, company dealerships, product distribution, and employment opportunities.

Vraishali wrote about the residential environment. She discussed old houses, new buildings, rental costs, traffic congestion, and problems involving public services.

Oraishi organized the survey results. She included figures showing what kinds of information students had known about Ganginapar before the project and how their perceptions had changed after learning new facts.

Adraim edited the interview sections. The date of each interview and the interviewee's professional background were recorded beside the relevant statements. Since permission had not been granted to disclose certain individuals' names, those names were not included.

While preparing the report, they encountered a problem. Some of the street names mentioned on an old map did not match the names currently in use.

Rivanbi asked, “Have these names been changed, or does the map refer to a different area?”

Adraim replied, “We need to find out for certain.”

Vraikun said, “We could ask the family that gave us the map for more information.”

Rivanbi replied, “Family accounts alone won't be enough. We need to compare them with old records or other published documents.”

They enlarged the photograph of the map and examined it again. Something resembling a date was written in one corner, but the paper was in such poor condition that they couldn't read the entire inscription.

They brought the matter to Professor Pragyaditya.

He said, “Don't present uncertain information as confirmed fact. You can mention the map as an old document preserved in a private family collection. But don't make a definite claim about its date or purpose.”

Rivanbi said, “Then we won't use the information from the map as primary evidence of the area's history.”

“That's the right decision.”

Once the draft was complete, everyone read it together. They found that some information had been repeated in several places. In other sections, interview statements had been mixed with their own analysis. They separated those parts and made the necessary revisions.

Rivanbi said, “Our personal opinions must not influence the way we present the facts.”

Vrainak replied, “Then the conclusion should describe the neighborhood's identity using only the information we've collected.”

Everyone agreed.

# Chapter Twenty-Nine

## Another Conversation with Her Family

One evening, Rivanbi was sitting at home reading the project report. Adraibon entered the room and sat beside her.

“Is the work almost finished?” he asked.

“The draft is ready. We're now verifying the information and editing the report.”

“How did you use the information from our family's old property documents?”

“I used only the details that matched other records. I didn't present anything we couldn't verify as confirmed information.”

Adraibon said, “Good. When people write about their family history, they sometimes try to make their family seem more important than it really is. Don't do that.”

Rivanbi replied, “I don't want this project to become a way of promoting our family's reputation.”

“Then remember something else. Our family lives and conducts business in Ganginapar. But this neighborhood's identity wasn't created by our family. Many other families, business owners, employees, and residents have contributed to it.”

Rivanbi said, “I've included that in the report.”

Adraibon remained silent for a moment. Then he asked, “Do people still bring up what happened on your first day at college?”

“Some still remember it. But now they understand that their perceptions of Ganginapar were incomplete.”

“Were you hurt by what happened that day?”

Rivanbi thought for a moment before answering.

“At first, I was surprised. I had simply told them where my home was. But a few people spoke as if the identity of one section of a neighborhood had somehow become my personal identity.”

Adraibon said, “People sometimes make comments without knowing the facts.”

“But not knowing isn't the problem, Dad. The real problem is judging someone without checking the facts, even when there's an opportunity to learn the truth.”

Adraibon looked at his daughter and said, “You've understood the issue well.”

Rivanbi replied, “I don't want anyone who reads our report to exaggerate or diminish Ganginapar. I want the neighborhood to be presented exactly as it is.”

Adraibon said, “Then your work will be successful.”

# Chapter Thirty

## The Final Review of the Report

The following day, the project members took their final draft to Professor Pragyaditya's office.

The professor picked up the report and read its title first:

**“Ganginapar: Urban Development, Economic Activities, and Social Identity.”**

He said, “That's an appropriate title. Now let's see how you've organized the information.”

He read the first section and then reviewed the description of the economic activities. In the section on the residential environment, he marked several sentences.

“Here you've written that all residents of Ganginapar are financially well-off because property values are high. You need to revise this statement.”

Rivanbi said, “Sir, what we actually wanted to say was that many properties in the area are valuable and that some families have owned them for generations.”

“Then write exactly that. You cannot conclude that every person living in an area is wealthy simply because property values are high.”

Vrainak said, “We'll revise the sentence.”

The professor moved on to the next section. There, the students had written that all the businesses in the neighborhood had been operating for many years.

He said, “This isn't accurate either. Some of the businesses you interviewed are old, but you cannot describe every establishment in the same way.”

Adraim said, “We'll write that the neighborhood has both long-established businesses and newer establishments.”

“Good.”

Next, the professor reviewed the survey section. It included the sample size, the types of questions asked, and the limitations concerning the respondents' backgrounds.

He said, “This section is well done. You've acknowledged the limitations of your own survey. That kind of honesty is essential in research.”

Vraishali asked, “Sir, should we add anything else to the section about commonly held perceptions?”

The professor replied, “You've shown that some students relied on things they had heard from others. You've also explained how their perceptions changed after they received new information. That's enough. But remember that your survey results are limited to the students who participated from your college.”

Rivanbi said, “We've mentioned that.”

The professor closed the report and said, “Now complete the final editing. You'll present it in the next class.”

The students left his office.

Rivanbi said, “Now it really feels like we're almost finished.”

Oraishi replied, “I never thought we'd come this far when we started with that question on the first day.”

Vraikun said, “It was a simple question. But while looking for the answer, we learned about so many different aspects of an entire neighborhood.”

Vrainak said, “And we realized that what we hear about something at first isn't necessarily the whole story.”

Rivanbi said, “We still have the final presentation to complete.”

# Chapter Thirty-One

## The Day of the Presentation

On the scheduled day, students gathered in the college auditorium. The project presentation was arranged in the same auditorium where the political science class had been held on the first day.

A large screen stood at the front of the stage. A computer and projector had been set up beside it. The students were making their final preparations.

Professor Pragyaditya walked onto the stage and said, “Today you'll present your project. Each of you will explain your own section. When answering questions, don't make claims that go beyond the information you've collected.”

Rivanbi and the other members of her team walked onto the stage.

Vraishali began by presenting the section on Ganginapar's location and urban development. She explained that Ganginapar was an important urban area in Mymensingh. Its commercial and residential roles had expanded alongside the city's development.

Next, Vrainak discussed the area's economic activities. Wholesale businesses, retail shops, company dealerships, product distribution, transportation, and employment opportunities were displayed on the screen.

Adraim explained the changes in the residential environment. He discussed old houses, new buildings, rental costs, traffic congestion, and problems involving public services.

Vraikun presented the findings from the interviews. The different realities of the neighborhood were illustrated through statements from business owners, employees, transportation workers, and residents.

Finally, Rivanbi stepped forward.

She said, “Our project began with a simple question. When one student said that she lived in Ganginapar and that she was a girl from Ganginapar, a few of her classmates misunderstood what she meant. They assumed that the identity of one particular section of the neighborhood represented the entire area.”

The auditorium fell silent.

Rivanbi continued, “We began collecting information based on that incident. As we continued our research, we discovered that Ganginapar has a much broader identity. It has old and new businesses, wholesale and retail trade, residential houses, people from different professions, employees, transportation workers, and various civic problems.”

She displayed several photographs on the screen. Images of old businesses, new buildings, residential streets, shops, and historical documents appeared one after another.

“We interviewed local residents. We examined old property deeds and business records. We also conducted a survey among students. However, we couldn't verify every piece of information to the same extent. Therefore, we did not present unverified information as confirmed fact.”

A student raised a hand.

The professor said, “Go ahead. Ask your question.”

The student asked, “If a particular social problem or controversial activity exists in Ganginapar, isn't that also part of the neighborhood's identity?”

Rivanbi replied, “Of course, it can be part of the area's reality. But the activities of one particular section cannot define the identity of the entire neighborhood. A city, for example, contains businesses, residential areas, educational institutions, and various social activities. None of those alone can be described as the city's only identity.”

Another student asked, “Did your research prove that every family in Ganginapar is wealthy?”

Rivanbi replied, “No. We made no such claim. Some land and properties in the area are highly valuable. Many families own properties there. But tenants, employees, small business owners, and people from different income groups also live in the neighborhood. Property values cannot determine the financial condition of every resident.”

The professor nodded.

Another student asked, “Did your survey include opinions from people outside the college?”

Vrainak answered, “No. Our survey was limited to college students. So we didn't present the results as representing the views of the wider population.”

After the question-and-answer session, Professor Pragyaditya picked up the microphone.

“One important aspect of your work is that you didn't rely solely on statements after encountering the misunderstanding on the first day. You collected information, conducted interviews, examined documents, and acknowledged the limitations of your own research.”

He looked at the students and continued, “To understand a neighborhood's identity, you must consider its history, economy, residents, and social realities together. One particular section cannot be established as the identity of the entire area.”

Applause filled the auditorium.

Rivanbi stepped down from the stage and stood beside her teammates.

# Chapter Thirty-Two

## A New Meaning Behind the Question

After the presentation ended, students began leaving the auditorium. The boy who had whispered on the first day that the girl from Ganginapar might live in a brothel was also there.

After hesitating for a moment, he approached Rivanbi.

“Can I talk to you for a minute?”

Rivanbi replied, “Sure. Go ahead.”

The boy said, “I made an unfair comment about you after hearing what you said on the first day. My understanding of Ganginapar was very limited back then. After listening to your presentation, I realized that I had spoken without knowing the whole story.”

Rivanbi calmly replied, “It's good that you understand it now.”

“Did what I said that day hurt you?”

“Yes, it did. I had simply told you where my home was. But you connected that statement to an identity that had nothing to do with what I had actually said.”

The boy lowered his head.

“I'm sorry.”

Rivanbi said, “In the future, whenever you hear something about a place or a person, check the facts before making comments. That will help prevent mistakes like this.”

The boy replied, “I'll try.”

Oraishi had been standing nearby and had heard their conversation. She said, “This doesn't apply only to Ganginapar. The same principle applies to every other neighborhood, too.”

The boy agreed.

A little later, several other students approached Rivanbi. They wanted to learn more about the project's findings. Some asked about the old businesses in the neighborhood. Others wanted to know why property values were so high in Ganginapar.

Rivanbi answered their questions. However, she did not provide details about her family's private properties or financial accounts.

She said, “You can refer to the information we've published in our project. There's no need to disclose details about private property.”

One student said, “After seeing your work, I realize that we used to rely mostly on things we had heard from others.”

Rivanbi replied, “Things people hear aren't always wrong. But it's not right to accept them as facts without verifying them.”

The students understood her point.

# Chapter Thirty-Three

## The Real Test of Change

After the project presentation, the college department decided to preserve the report. Professor Pragyaditya informed the students that further research could be conducted in the future on social and economic changes in urban areas.

Rivanbi and her team members prepared an edited copy of the report. The interviewees' personal identities were kept confidential. Documents whose information they had not received permission to disclose were not included.

Although the project had ended, discussions about Ganginapar continued.

Some students at the college began talking among themselves about the area's businesses and residential environment. Some wanted to learn more about specific establishments before going there to shop. Others became interested in the history of old buildings and businesses.

One day, Oraishi said, “Do you remember how everyone looked at you in the auditorium on the first day?”

Rivanbi replied, “I remember.”

“People don't talk that way anymore.”

“Not everyone has changed. But at least some people have understood the issue.”

Oraishi asked, “Do you think our project changed their perceptions?”

“It may have changed the views of some people. But one project can't change everyone's perceptions. People have to learn the facts and examine their own assumptions.”

A few days later, Ganginapar's identity became a topic of discussion again at a college event. This time, a student said during a speech, “The phrase 'a girl from Ganginapar' simply refers to someone's place of residence. No one's personal character or social identity can be determined by that address.”

Rivanbi heard the statement from a distance.

She felt that many things had changed since the incident on the first day. However, the discussion was no longer limited to her personal experience. People had also begun talking about the importance of critical thinking and verifying information.

# Chapter Thirty-Four

## An Afternoon in Ganginapar

One afternoon, instead of going straight home from college, Rivanbi began walking along a familiar road in Ganginapar.

The shops along the road were open. Goods were being unloaded in some places, while customers negotiated prices in others. In front of one business establishment, several employees were checking their accounts. Nearby, family members were busy with their daily activities outside their homes.

She stopped beside an old house. Its walls bore the marks of time. The wooden window frames had aged, but the house was still in use.

A short distance away, a new building was under construction. The workers were busy with their tasks.

Rivanbi looked around. Through her project, she had gained a much better understanding of how many different kinds of lives existed side by side in this neighborhood.

An elderly businessman standing in front of a shop recognized her and called out.

“Were you one of the students who worked on that college project?”

Rivanbi replied, “Yes. I also collected information from you.”

“Have you submitted your report?”

“Yes. We've finished the presentation, too.”

The businessman said, “It was good that you listened to people's experiences. Many people just look at the shops and walk away. Nobody wants to know about the people who work here.”

Rivanbi replied, “Their experiences are also part of the neighborhood's history.”

The businessman nodded.

“That's right. A neighborhood's identity isn't defined only by its houses and shops. The people who work here every day are part of that identity, too.”

Rivanbi said goodbye and continued walking.

When she reached home, she saw her father sitting on the veranda. Adraibon looked at her and said, “You're a little late today.”

“I was walking around a few places in the neighborhood on my way home from college.”

“Are you still exploring the area even though the project is over?”

“The project is finished, but the neighborhood is still here. There's something new to notice every day.”

Adraibon asked, “What do you think you accomplished through your work?”

Rivanbi replied, “We collected information. Some people's misconceptions have changed. But the most important thing is that I also learned many things about the neighborhood that I hadn't understood before.”

“What kind of things?”

“I used to think of Ganginapar simply as the place where I live. Now I understand how much is connected to its history, businesses, people's work, and civic problems.”

Adraibon said, “There's no end to learning.”

Rivanbi smiled. “That's true.”

# Chapter Thirty-Five

## The Answer to the Final Question

At the next political science class, Professor Pragyaditya entered the auditorium just as he had on the first day. The students were seated in their usual places.

Before beginning the class, he said, “Your project is now complete. Today, I'd like to return to a question from the first day.”

The students paid attention.

The professor continued, “One student asked me whether studying political science could make them political scientists. I answered that question that day. Now I'd like to ask you something. Can studying a subject teach you everything about its real-world conditions?”

Several students raised their hands.

Vrainak said, “No, sir. Studying gives us an understanding of a subject. But to learn about reality, we also need to collect information and make observations.”

The professor said, “Exactly.”

Vraishali added, “Even if we already have an opinion about something, we must be willing to revise it when we receive new information.”

The professor nodded in agreement.

Then he looked at Rivanbi.

“Would you like to say something?”

Rivanbi stood up.

“Sir, on the first day, I simply said that our home was in Ganginapar and that I was a girl from Ganginapar. But others interpreted my words according to their own assumptions. Later, when we collected information, we realized that a neighborhood's identity is much broader. It includes different kinds of people, professions, businesses, residential lives, and social realities.”

The professor asked, “Then what is your answer to the question from the first day?”

Rivanbi replied, “Sir, when I say I'm a girl from Ganginapar, it simply means that Ganginapar is where I live. Beyond that, nobody has the right to make assumptions about my personal identity.”

Silence fell over the auditorium.

She continued, “An entire neighborhood cannot be judged by the identity of just one of its sections. And someone's character cannot be determined by the address where that person lives.”

Professor Pragyaditya looked at her for a few moments.

Then he said, “That's an appropriate answer.”

A few students began applauding. Gradually, applause spread throughout the auditorium.

Rivanbi returned to her seat.

On the first day, a misunderstanding about her identity had arisen in that very auditorium. Today, in the same place, she had been able to express her position clearly.

After class, Oraishi came and stood beside her.

“Have you finally received an answer to your question?”

Rivanbi replied, “The answer was there from the first day. It just took others some time to understand it.”

The two of them walked out of the auditorium together.

Outside, the afternoon light spread across the college grounds. Students were moving along the road in front of the college. Some were heading home, others were going to the library, and some were talking with their friends.

Rivanbi no longer felt uncomfortable about her identity. Ganginapar was her home. She was interested in its history, economy, people's lives, and ongoing changes. But no popular assumption or someone else's comment could define her personal identity.

She knew that Ganginapar's identity could not be summed up in a single word. The neighborhood had old businesses and new establishments, residential houses and people from different professions. It also had civic problems and a history of change.

All these things together made Ganginapar what it was.

And she was a girl from Ganginapar. (The End.) ©️All Right Reserved by Junayed Ashrafur Rahman

24°33'58.6"N 90°41'30.4"E

My home Location ✒ https://goo.gl/maps/RoKi3ekrhkm5PAHPA , But I don't live here. Rented out to other people.

Nandail Municipality, Mymensingh, Bangladesh.

Junayedmn1@gmail.com

My Writings ✒ https://www.blogger.com/profile/11734624718328723069

702) My success in writing. (লেখালেখিতে আমার সাফল্য।) – Written by Junayed Ashrafur Rahman ✒ https://literatureforalljunayedmn1.blogspot.com/2023/06/702-my-success-in-writing-written-by.html

707)After the fantasy of ministry.(মন্ত্রিত্বের ফ্যান্টাসির পরে।)– Written by Junayed Ashrafur Rahman ✒ https://mytimemyexperiencesjunayedmn1.blogspot.com/2023/06/707after-fantasy-of-ministry-written-by.html

637)Win prizes.(পুরস্কার জিতুন।) - Written by Junayed Ashrafur ✒ https://literatureforalljunayedmn1.blogspot.com/2022/10/637win-prizes-written-by-junayed.html

667)Case against AI ChatGPT. (এআই চ্যাট জিপিটির বিরুদ্ধে মামলা।) – Written by Junayed Ashrafur Rahman ✒ https://lawforjusticejunayedmn1.blogspot.com/2023/02/667case-against-chat-gpt-written-by.html http://ow.ly/Zawy104u7kO

#Intellectualproperty #Literature #Law #Contract #Writing #Wisdom